Category: Sports

  • Hearts 25/26 Season Hangover

    Hearts 25/26 Season Hangover

    From Title Challengers to a Rebuild: A Hearts Fan’s Reality Check

    Well, here’s a big brain dump.

    Last season (2025/26, for when I inevitably come back to this in five years wondering what I was talking about) Hearts did something incredible. We came within five minutes of winning the Scottish Premiership.

    For months people had written us off. Every dropped point was apparently proof we’d bottled it. But looking back now, I don’t buy that narrative.

    It wasn’t a bottle job.

    It was a genuine title challenge from a team that earned the right to be there.

    Unfortunately, we don’t deserve to be there anymore.

    That hurts to admit because it’s not where I want Hearts to be. I want us competing with Celtic and Rangers every season, not hoping for the occasional run. But it’s important to separate what we want from what we are.

    The truth is we probably weren’t a title-winning side last year either.

    Everything just came together at exactly the right time. We had momentum, players exceeded expectations, new signings clicked, and we rode that wave almost all the way to the title. It was football’s version of catching lightning in a bottle.

    This season feels like the hangover.

    Derek McInnes’ Lasting Impact

    Last season Derek McInnes was both the biggest reason we finished second and, strangely enough, one of the reasons we didn’t finish first.

    Over the course of the season he built a disciplined, organised side that believed it belonged near the top. Without him there’s no title race.

    But looking back at those final months, there are a handful of games where we retreated when we should have kept attacking. There were draws that felt like victories at the time but, with hindsight, should have been wins.

    Five minutes separated us from history, but a few more positive decisions earlier in the run-in might have meant those final five minutes never mattered.

    Injuries Changed Everything

    We were also hit at exactly the wrong time.

    Lawrence Shankland’s injury stalled our momentum. Defensive injuries piled up. Ageu, who was supposed to be one of the marquee signings, got injured almost immediately, forcing another rethink.

    Even then, there were positives.

    Braga was outstanding. Kyziridis looked capable of making something happen whenever he got on the ball. Marc Leonard brought calm and balance to midfield.

    The squad wasn’t perfect, but it found ways to compete.

    Reality Has Arrived

    This season was always going to be difficult.

    You can’t expect to recreate a once-in-a-generation title challenge simply because most of the players are still wearing the same shirt.

    Then came the departures.

    Losing players to Rangers gutted the spine of the team. We still haven’t adequately replaced Lawrence Shankland or Cammy Devlin, and that’s impossible to ignore.

    I really wanted JJ Williams to succeed.

    Every Hearts supporter wants new signings to work because it’s better for everyone when they do. But every time I’ve watched him he looks unsure of where he’s supposed to be. He doesn’t create space for himself, doesn’t create space for teammates, and when chances do arrive they too often disappear without troubling the goalkeeper.

    Maybe he’ll come good.

    Right now, though, he simply hasn’t.

    There Are Still Reasons for Optimism

    It’s not all doom and gloom.

    Josh McPake has been exciting to watch. Calvin Miller has added genuine attacking threat. Tom Renaud has impressed me every time I’ve seen him.

    Once again, though, injuries seem determined to stop any momentum before it starts.

    That has become a frustrating theme.

    This Is a Project

    I’ve deliberately avoided talking too much about Wouter Vrancken because I don’t think he’s the problem.

    If anything, he’s almost gone too far in the opposite direction from McInnes. Last season we could be too cautious. This season we sometimes look too eager to attack without enough defensive balance.

    That’s something that can be coached.

    More importantly, I think he’s getting about as much out of this squad as anyone could right now.

    He deserves time.

    This isn’t a finished team; it’s a project.

    Success this season shouldn’t be measured by whether we challenge for the title again. That was never realistic after everything that happened.

    Success should be measured by developing young players, building a coherent style of play, and qualifying for Europe.

    If we can do those three things, we’ll have something far more valuable than a brief title challenge.

    We’ll have the foundations for the next one.